STONEFORM Brianform — Made in Italy
IT / EN

Guides · Technique

Do you need an upstand behind a stone worktop?

In short. There is always a gap between a stone worktop and the wall, and not because the worktop was cut badly: because the wall is not a straight line. It gets closed in three ways — silicone, a separate upstand, an upstand cut from the worktop's own slab — and they are three decisions taken at three different moments. The most important one has to be taken before the stone is bought.

Why is there always a gap between worktop and wall?

A stone worktop is cut along a straight line. A plastered wall, even a well-built one, is not: it has a drift, it is a few millimetres out of plumb, and it almost never meets the base units at an exact right angle. Contact happens where the wall bulges out and stays open where it falls back: along the same run the gap can be an invisible line at one end and a shadow seen from across the room at the other.

This is no fault of the worktop, and it is why a worktop is never pushed against the wall to close the gap: stone does not deform, and forcing it means making it bear on a few points instead of along its whole side, which is the condition cracks come from — the same principle as the guide on cracks at the sink cutout. The real question is not how to make the gap disappear: it is how to close it, and who will have to maintain it.

Is silicone on its own enough?

Often yes, and in many homes it is the right choice: it takes no depth from the worktop and adds no line to the stone's pattern. But it has to be understood for what it is, namely an elastic joint: a sealing element meant to move, and therefore one that ages.

Anyone who treats it as permanent finds out in the worst place, the rim of the basin, where water stands and where a failed joint does damage that shows on the stone and not on the silicone, as in the guide on a tap leaking at its base.

When is a separate upstand worth it?

It is the middle solution: a vertical band of stone, the same material as the worktop, resting on the worktop and set against the wall. It raises the point of contact, so the joint that has to hold water is no longer on the edge of the working surface but behind a barrier. In a bathroom that changes a great deal.

What it does not solve is the number of joints: they become two instead of one, and the first — between worktop and upstand — is horizontal, which is where water stops. The advantage is real only if that joint is made as a joint between two pieces of stone and not as an exposed silicone bead. And there is the pattern: a separate upstand is a separate piece, and unless it is cut from the slab next to the worktop's own, the veining breaks at the line where they meet. On a uniform ground nobody notices; on a calacatta or an arabescato they do.

What is an upstand cut from the same slab, and why must it be decided first?

It is a band taken from the worktop's own slab, immediately adjacent to the worktop piece, and fitted so that the veining continues: the pattern rises from the worktop onto the wall without a break. On heavily veined stones you can go further and mirror it, as in the bookmatched layout of the guide on how long a marble top can be without seams.

The practical point, though, is a question of slab area rather than of workmanship: an upstand cut from the slab consumes slab. It needs a continuous band, as long as the run, next to the worktop piece, and the slab has to be chosen in the knowledge that it will have to hold both. Anyone who buys it for the worktop alone, and decides on the upstand afterwards, finds the adjacent band has been cut for another piece: from that moment only the separate upstand remains, with veining that does not continue.

That is why it is the first of the three decisions and not the last: it is not a question of the quotation, it is a question of what gets bought. How to look at a slab before cutting it is in the guide on how to pick a marble slab.

The joint is then made the way any joint between two pieces of stone is made: dressed edges, minimal gap, adhesive pigmented to the colour of the stone's ground and not to its veining. On an upstand it sits in plain view at eye level, and how it meets the worktop's edge follows the criteria of the guide on the edge profile of a stone top.

And if the wall is visibly out of true?

Then there is a choice between three things, and it is better made than discovered on fitting day.

Is the answer the same in a hotel?

No, and the reason is not technical: the person cleaning changes. In a home the worktop is cleaned by whoever chose it; in a hotel it is cleaned every day by someone who did not choose it, with a product set by a specification, in the time allowed for turning a room around. A silicone joint, in those conditions, gets dirty in every room at the same spot and gets redone in every room at once: it is a maintenance item multiplied by the rooms, not a detail. Here an upstand from the slab becomes an operational choice: it takes a joint out of the wet zone and puts stone there instead.

As for what will then reach the stone, the guide on why a bathroom top marks first holds; on who supplies and who fits on a hotel contract, the guide on who supplies stone tops for hotels.

What to decide, and in what order?

How we work

In our quarry the blocks are cut to the client's instructions, and this is one of the cases where that matters: a slab sawn for the piece in hand holds the upstand too, instead of ruling it out. When we do not have a stone as a block we buy the slabs from importers we trust, and then the upstand is taken from the adjacent slab, selected and numbered together with the worktop's. Before cutting we look at the slabs against the light: that is how you see where the pattern runs, and therefore where the joint is best placed. For a contract supply the route is the Contract section; the contacts lead to the people who follow the work, and the tables show how we work when there is only one piece to make.

Frequently asked questions

Can an upstand be added later, once the worktop is fitted?

A separate upstand, yes, and it is a simple job. One from the same slab, no, because the adjacent slab is gone: all that remains is an upstand cut from another slab, with a pattern that does not continue.

How tall should an upstand be?

There is no single right height: it depends on how far the water reaches and how far the eye reaches. The two conditions are that it covers the area that gets wet and that it stops where another element begins — a wall unit, a socket, a cladding — because an upstand that ends behind something is a line nobody sees and an edge nobody can clean.

Does white or clear silicone age better?

It is not the colour that decides, but the width of the joint and how clean the surface it is laid on is: on a greasy or dusty surface it will come away whatever colour it is.

Ask for a quotation The tables collection

This page describes assessment and selection criteria; it quotes no prices, no response times and no company case histories. The guidance on joint position, fit and adhesive is that of good stoneworking practice and has to be verified case by case, because it depends on the stone, on the run and on the structure beneath the worktop. No technical standard is cited, because the applicable requirements change with the use of the room.